PHILADELPHIA — Bill Cosby's lawyers will argue Tuesday that prosecutors are reaching back to the “casting couch” era to round up female accusers and build a “stale” sexual assault case against him.
And they will take a Pennsylvania judge through a time warp to prove their point, challenging sexual misconduct claims that spanned the freewheeling 1960s, patriotic 1980s and gender-bending 21st century.
Cosby arrived just before 9 a.m. at the Montgomery County Courthouse, smiling as he chatted with his handlers.
Prosecutors will ask the judge to let 13 other women testify at the scheduled June trial that they were drugged and molested by Cosby in a “signature” fashion.
However, defense lawyers note there's little but hazy memories to go on. In a defense filing Monday, they said the women's memories have been compromised by time and widespread media coverage of the case.
“The fact that even the most fervently held memories can actually be tainted — or altogether false — is supported by a vast existing and growing body of science,” lawyers Brian McMonagle and Angela Agrusa wrote.
The pretrial hearing is expected to last two days, with another hearing on the evidence set for December.
Cosby, now 79 and blind, remains free on $1 million bail. It's been a half-century since the comedian became the first black actor to star in a primetime TV show, “I Spy,” and more than 20 years since his top-ranked homage to black family life, “The Cosby Show,” stopped filming.
He had beaten back a Temple University employee's sexual assault complaint in 2005 when prosecutors said there wasn't enough evidence to charge him.
But a new prosecutor, District Attorney Kevin Steele, reopened the Montgomery County case last year amid new evidence: the scores of public accusers and a newly unsealed deposition that showed Cosby acknowledging he gave Andrea Constand three unlabeled pills and some wine before sticking his hand down her pants. Constand, then 30, said she was only semi-conscious after taking what she thought were herbal pills. She had met Cosby, a Temple booster, through her job and said she went to his house that night for career advice.
Constand settled a lawsuit against Cosby in 2006. The defense, in their motion Monday, said her accounts of her relationship with Cosby changed in her initial police statements — and they said the two had been intimate before.
They also took aim at prosecution claims that Cosby attacked vulnerable young women in “signature” fashion after offering to mentor them. Defense lawyers challenge the point, saying the women had different types of friendships with Cosby, met him in different cities and were various ages. The defense will ask Judge Steven O'Neill to bar their “prior bad act” testimony.
“Even if proven (and it could not be), the age-old ‘casting couch’ is not unique to Mr. Cosby, and thus not a ‘signature’ nor a basis for the admissibility of these witnesses’ stories, let alone a conviction,” the defense lawyers wrote.
The judge has so far sided with prosecutors in refusing to dismiss the case.
- Cosby jokes in first show since 2015 he 'used to be' comedian
- Opening statements set in Bill Cosby's sex assault retrial
- Constand to confront Cosby after parade of women take aim
- At impasse, Cosby jury goes back to work on verdict
- Cosby venue could move to California in sex abuse lawsuit
- What will the #MeToo movement mean for Cosby's next trial?
- Bill Cosby's day of reckoning comes in sex assault case
- Bill Cosby sentenced to 3 to 10 years in prison on sex assault charges
- Bill Cosby's defenders see him as victim of racism, sexism
- Cosby team turns to star witness with drug experts on deck
- Jury gets case after Cosby painted as predator, victim
- Will Bill Cosby, 81, go to prison? A judge is set to decide
- Race, gender, fame all issues as Cosby jury selection starts
- Cosby's lawyer attacks 1 accuser as sex assault trial opens
- Cosby accuser to resume testimony in sex assault trial
- Cosby judge to weigh potential testimony of 13 other women
- Cosby, a year later: Will he seek deal or prepare for trial?
- Cosby to ask judge for outside jury for criminal trial
- Bill Cosby jury to hear more of his deposition testimony
- Growing frenzy outside court as Cosby deliberations wear on
- Tensions rise as Bill Cosby jury struggles to reach verdict
- Jury may soon hear from Cosby, even if he doesn't take stand
- Jury to hear Bill Cosby's testimony about quaaludes and sex
- Will Cosby testify at sex assault trial? Lawyers remain mum
- Cosby held for trial; attorneys show glimpse of defense in preliminary hearing
- Bill Cosby due in suburban Philadelphia court for preliminary hearing on sex crime allegations
- Cosby’s lawyers seek to dismiss defamation case from model Dickinson
- Judge rules Cosby case can proceed; preliminary hearing scheduled for March 8
- Judge could rule on Cosby’s bid to dismiss sexual assault case; comedian claims he was promised immunity
- Cosby due in court as lawyers push to get charges dropped
- Cosby supporters waning amid feelings of betrayal
- BREAKING: Bill Cosby charged with sexual assault in suburban Philadelphia