ALEXANDRIA, Va. — Prosecutors are expected to rest their case Friday against former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort, after days of occasionally dramatic testimony in Manafort's bank fraud and tax evasion trial and some testy exchanges with the trial judge.
Prosecuting attorneys for special counsel Robert Mueller got a rare, and narrow, acknowledgment from U.S. District Judge T.S. Ellis III that he likely erred when he angrily confronted them a day earlier.
The judge's comments came Thursday, during the eighth day of trial, as prosecutors began presenting the bulk of their bank fraud case after spending days largely on tax evasion allegations.
Thursday's testimony was devoid of some of the drama of recent days, when longtime Manafort deputy Rick Gates was confronted about having embezzled hundreds of thousands of dollars from Manafort and was forced to admit on the witness stand to an extramarital affair.
On Thursday, a group of bank employees told jurors about discrepancies and outright falsehoods contained on Manafort's loan applications.
Melinda James, a Citizens Bank mortgage loan assistant, testified that Manafort told the bank that a New York City property would be used as a second residence, but she found it listed as a rental on a real estate website. That distinction matters because banks regard loans for rental, or investment, properties as riskier and may impose restrictions, including on how much money they're willing to lend.
Jurors saw an email from Manafort to his son-in-law, Jeffrey Yohai, in which he advised him that an appraiser was looking to schedule a visit to the property.
“Remember, he believes that you and Jessica are living there,” Manafort wrote in the email, referencing his daughter.
Airbnb executive Darin Evenson also told jurors that one of Manafort's New York City properties was offered as a rental through much of 2015 and 2016 — a direct contradiction of the documents the longtime political consultant submitted to obtain a $3.4 million loan.
Manafort also asserted on a loan application that he did not have a mortgage on a separate New York property, even though he actually did, and signed paperwork indicating he understood that he could face criminal penalties for providing false information to the bank.
The prosecution has called more than 20 witnesses, including Gates, and introduced a trove of documentary evidence as they've sought to prove Manafort defrauded banks and concealed millions of dollars in offshore bank accounts from the IRS. But along the way they've not only faced an aggressive defense team but a combative relationship with Ellis.
The judge has subjected the prosecution to repeated tongue-lashings over the pace of their questioning, their large amount of trial exhibits and even their facial expressions. But on Thursday, Ellis told jurors he went overboard when he erupted at prosecutors a day earlier for allowing an expert witness to remain in the courtroom during the trial.
“Put aside my criticism,” Ellis said, adding, “This robe doesn't make me anything other than human.”
Prosecutors had asked Ellis to tell the jury that he made an error in admonishing them during the Wednesday testimony of IRS agent Michael Welch.
Ellis had heatedly confronted prosecutor Uzo Asonye, saying he hadn't authorized Welch to watch the entirety of the trial. Witnesses are usually excluded from watching unless allowed by the judge.
But in their filing, prosecutors attached a transcript showing that in fact Ellis had approved the request a week before. They said his outburst prejudiced the jury by suggesting they had acted improperly and could undermine Welch's testimony.
“The Court's sharp reprimand of government counsel in front of the jury on August 8 was therefore erroneous,” prosecutors wrote. “And, while mistakes are a natural part of the trial process, the mistake here prejudiced the government by conveying to the jury that the government had acted improperly and had violated court rules or procedures.”
Welch had told jurors that Manafort didn't report at least $16 million on his tax returns between 2010 and 2014. He also said Manafort should have reported multiple foreign bank accounts to the IRS in those years.
On Thursday, they also asked Ellis to seal portions of a bench conversation during Gates’ testimony because “substantive evidence” in an ongoing investigation was discussed. Prosecutors didn't elaborate, but one bench conference came after Manafort's defense team tried to question Gates about whether he had discussed his work on the Trump campaign with Mueller's team.
The judge agreed Thursday night to seal the portion of the sidebar.
Neither Manafort nor Gates was charged in connection with their Trump campaign work, but the special counsel continues to investigate Russian election interference and any ties to associates of the president.
- Rick Gates' testimony dredges up Trump inaugural spending mystery
- Jury to begin deliberating in Manafort financial fraud trial
- The Latest: Manafort found guilty on 8 of 18 counts (UPDATED)
- Jury returns guilty verdict on eight charges in Paul Manafort charges; 10 more declared mistrial
- Paul Manafort signals he intends to plead guilty before new trial
- Probes of Donald Trump taxes carry potential for millions in fines
- Robert Mueller accuses Paul Manafort of breaking plea agreement by lying
- Report: Paul Manafort met with Julian Assange ahead of 2016 leaks
- New developments put Manafort back in Russia probe spotlight
- Trump on Paul Manafort pardon: 'I wouldn't take it off the table'
- Court deadlines set stage for more Russia probe details
- Cross-examination focuses on Manafort protege's own crimes (UPDATED)
- Star witness against Paul Manafort admits embezzling from him
- Trump appears to change story on meeting with Russian lawyer
- Testimony by 'right-hand man' critical in Manafort trial
- Bookkeeper: Manafort didn't disclose foreign accounts to her
- White House: Trump's tweet about Russia probe was an opinion
- Donald Trump calls on Jeff Sessions to end Robert Mueller's Russia probe
- Manafort accused of amassing 'secret income' as trial opens
- Trial set to begin for ex-Trump campaign chairman Manafort
- Manafort trial to shed light on Mueller probe evidence
- Judge jails ex-Trump campaign chair Paul Manafort ahead of trial
- Manafort accused of several tries to tamper with witnesses
- The princes, the president and the fortune seekers
- The year of Mueller: 12 months in, here's what we've learned
- Special counsel team has floated idea of subpoena for Trump