HOUSTON — Two Octobers after sparking a reliever revolution, Andrew Miller came up empty.
Miller failed to get an out in relief of starter Carlos Carrasco, allowing a go-ahead double to Marwin Gonzalez as the Cleveland Indians lost to Houston 3-1 Saturday and fell into a 2-0 AL Division Series deficit.
“I wasn’t good,” Miller said. “I wasn’t effective.”
Miller’s ineffectual outing would have been a stunner two years ago, when manager Terry Francona leaned on him for as many as eight outs at a time while Cleveland made it all the way to Game 7 of the World Series. It was game-changing when Francona called on Miller as early as the fifth inning that fall, but such aggressive bullpen management has become common around the majors since.
Miller hasn’t been the same this year, a season that included three stints on the disabled list.
Cleveland was clinging to a 1-0 lead with two on and one out in the sixth when Francona called on Miller. Gonzalez immediately drove a two-run double to deep right field.
“With a one-run lead, and with Gonzalez coming up the way he had swung the bat against him prior and Andrew’s history, I felt really good about it,” Francona said.
“Didn’t work out the way we obviously planned.”
Miller then walked Carlos Correa, let both runners advance on a wild pitch and intentionally walked Tyler White before Francona came for the ball.
“It’s my job to get through that inning. I didn’t do it,” Miller said. “That’s what it boils down to. I got ahead, and then I didn’t get a fastball where I wanted to, and everything kind of spiraled from there. Not a good job, poor execution.”
Miller had allowed only one previous inherited runner to score in his postseason career, when David Ortiz brought in Dustin Pedroia with a sacrifice fly for Boston during Game 3 of the 2016 AL Division Series. Cleveland won that game 4-3.
The lanky lefty had a 4.24 ERA this season, his highest since a 5.54 mark mostly as a starting pitcher for Boston in 2011. He was sharper down the stretch until getting hit around by the last-place Kansas City in his last regular-season appearance.
“It’s frustrating,” Miller said. “I don’t know about the last couple appearances. Those were a week ago. I felt like I was throwing the ball well coming into this.”
Francona’s other option in that spot was right-hander Trevor Bauer, an AL Cy Young Award contender as a starter before a line drive broke a bone in his right leg in August.
Francona said he didn’t consider bringing in Bauer instead of Miller for Carrasco.
“We wanted Andrew,” he said. “That’s what we wanted right there.”
Bauer looked sharp in three abbreviated outings at the end of the regular season, and Francona had said Bauer could be a Miller-like long-relief option this October.
That hasn’t worked out, either. Bauer entered in the seventh inning of the opening 7-2 loss and allowed an RBI single to Bregman, as well as a double to Yuli Gurriel. Bauer then relieved Miller on Saturday and pitched out of a bases-loaded jam before allowing a solo homer to Bregman in the next inning.
Francona is running out of reliable options.
Longtime closer Cody Allen allowed Martin Maldonado’s homer in Game 1, and Dan Otero gave up a run in the eighth inning of that game. On Saturday, closer Brad Hand allowed two baserunners before pitching out of the eighth. Only sidearmer Adam Cimber has managed to avoid trouble through two games.
The bullpen was an issue all season, ranking 25th in the majors with a 4.60 ERA. Cleveland still cruised to its third straight AL Central title largely by leaning on its overpowering starting rotation. Its relievers accounted for the fewest innings in the majors.
Yet Francona was quick to yank Carrasco, after 77 pitches.
Facing elimination in Game 3 on Monday, the Indians will be hoping for more from Mike Clevinger. Otherwise, this October may be a short one for the 2016 AL champs.
- ALDS: Indians need 'Sunshine' ... Mike Clevinger ... to provide a ray of hope against Astros
- Astros 11, Indians 3: Tribe's season ends in disappointing fashion for second straight year
- Trevor Bauer's move to bullpen fails to pay off for Indians
- Jim Ingraham: Indians have a nice little team that needs some serious shaking up
- Not good enough: Indians built to contend for World Series titles but keep falling short
- Ingraham: The Indians clearly need an offseason makeover
- Cardinals agree to 2-year deal with reliever Andrew Miller
- Astros 3, Indians 1: Tribe sinks into 0-2 hole in ALDS after another anemic offensive effort
- Astros 7, Indians 2: Tribe gets off to rough start in ALDS as Corey Kluber, offense struggle
- Commentary: Bullpen is Tribe's biggest weakness when ALDS opens Friday
- Indians' ALDS roster nearly set; Tomlin doesn't make the cut, Davis not assured of spot
- Indians ready for big test as ALDS matchup looms with Astros
- Indians commentary: Tribe needs Jose Ramirez to turn it around at the plate
- Jim Ingraham: Trevor Bauer returns from injury at the perfect time
- Chris Assenheimer: Overlooking the Indians in the postseason might be easy to do, but it's definitely not advisable
- Jim Ingraham: Plenty of reasons to feel good ... and bad ... about the Indians' postseason chances
- Jim Ingraham: As good as the Indians have been the last two years, this year's team has a chance to be even better