GOODYEAR, Ariz. — Presumably, they will all be ready to pitch the first week of the season. Right now, Cleveland’s loaded starting rotation is in limbo.
With the March 28 opener at Minnesota drawing near, manager Terry Francona has yet to say who he will start against the Twins or how he will configure his starters in the early stages of the season.
There is a lot to consider.
Potential trades involving two-time Cy Young winner Corey Kluber and All-Star Trevor Bauer never materialized this winter, leaving the lndians with an arsenal of right-handers, including Carlos Carrasco, Mike Clevinger and Shane Bieber. The strength of the rotation is one reason the Indians are predicted to win the AL Central for the fourth consecutive year.
Francona and pitching coach Carl Willis are evaluating how to seize momentum in April by lining up the pitchers in the most efficient early season order.
“We want to keep Trevor in between Carrasco and Kluber, the reason being, for early in the season, Trevor is the one guy situated to probably go deeper in the games,” Francona said of Bauer, who went 12-6 with a 2.21 ERA in 28 starts last season. “Staffs are never quite stretched out when the season starts, so Trevor is the one guy (stretched out). So we want to keep him in between, so we don’t tax our bullpen.”
Bauer, a proponent of frequent throwing, along with long toss and weighted ball use, has started three Cactus League games, completing 11 innings, including extensive experimentation on his new change-up.
Bieber, in his first major league camp, has made three starts, for nine innings.
Clevinger pitched for the first time Wednesday, Carrasco won his spring debut Sunday against the Mariners — three innings, three hits, two earned runs, one walk and four strikeouts — while Kluber will make his today.
“We have it lined up where Kluber could go Game 1 or later if need be,” Francona said. “We’ve kind of lined it up where we can do some things. At some point, you kind of have to make a decision, but Carl’s done a good job. Like we have one game where Kluber’s pitching and Clev’s (Clevinger) coming in after him. Then, we’ll separate them after that. Clev needs to repeat his three innings, and so he’ll do it coming in after Kluber.”
If Kluber rested five days between Cactus League starts, he would start again Sunday and March 23. Then, on four days’ rest, his fourth consecutive opening day assignment is conceivable.
The prestige of starting opening day is another factor. Francona was asked if the feelings of a player should be a factor.
“We try to take into consideration what’s best for our team,” he said. “We try to instill in our guys team-first attitudes, also recognizing that there are some things (that matter). Yeah, we get it. We’ve talked to Kluber about it. I think he’d like to be ready for that opening day. And if he is, for all he’s done, he’s very worthy of pitching on opening day.”
In the next breath, Francona noted that Bauer and Carrasco are worthy of getting the ball on opening day, too.
“We’re pretty fortunate in that we got pitchers — that if something happened — we could throw any of them out there and we feel like we got a good chance to win,” he said.
Catcher Kevin Plawecki, who was acquired in a trade with the Mets on Jan. 6, spent the past four seasons working with exceptional starters Jacob deGrom and Noah Syndergaard. He knows the Indians have something unusual.
“The guys here are all special,” he said. “One through five, you are going to have a guy who has a chance to win every night.”
The quintet is at different stages of their careers.
Bieber, 23, is at the beginning. The former University of California-Santa Barbara standout rose from Double A to win 11 games and post a 4.55 ERA last season.
Carrasco, who will turn 33 on March 21, recorded more than 215 strikeouts in three of the past four seasons.
Clevinger, 28, combined with Kluber, 32, to become the fourth duo in Indians history to pitch at least 200 innings and exceed 200 strikeouts.
Bauer, 28, pitched so deeply into games last year that he logged 175.1 innings, one fewer than in 2017 despite missing six weeks recovering from a stress fracture in his fibula, the result of being hit by a line drive Aug. 12.
“Trevor Bauer had a year that was like a kind of a coming out (party),” Francona said. “And I actually think he’s going to get better with the development of his change-up.”
- Corey Kluber takes mound for first time this spring
- Commentary: Indians manager Terry Francona loves a challenge ... and should get a big one this season
- Indians name Corey Kluber opening day starter for fifth straight season
- Indians preview 2019: It's nice to have some things to count on -- like Corey Kluber
- Indians preview 2019: Rotation remains Tribe's best chance at success
- Mike Clevinger brings the heat, averages 95 mph, strikes out career-high 12 in dominant debut
- Commentary: Dominant Trevor Bauer will make things really interesting in near-future
- Jim Ingraham: Corey Kluber not himself so far this season
- Commentary: Pressure building for Indians in 2019 with Corey Kluber, Trevor Bauer likely on way out
- Indians spring training preview: Big changes bring big questions and big concerns
- Commentary: More pressure on Indians' rotation to produce this year
- Jim Ingraham: Indians manager Terry Francona is facing real challenges this season
- Indians' Trevor Bauer not bothered by trade rumors but don't ask him about Twitter
- Jim Ingraham: Indians' recent deals might be the way they keep their star-studded rotation together